Home ›

Habeas (the tiniest little bit of my) corpus

25
02
08

Habeas (the tiniest little bit of my) corpus

tagged with:
Printer-friendly versionSend to friendPDF version

Hat tip to a wonderful post from South Africa about Britain's surveillance culture in which Chris Rodrigues reminds us that it was Nicolae Ceausescu who often pushed the surveillance state in totalitarian Romania with the now much overused saying that "if you've got nothing to hide you've got nothing to worry about".

We hear it all the time in Britain whenever someone starts complaining about the "surveillance state", as if just not being a criminal makes it okay to have your movements tracked, your DNA held on file or your telephone tapped. And yet again, in the wake of the two high profile convictions last week of Steve Wright and Mark Dixie, people have been calling for a full national DNA database.

Whilst it's not a terribly palatable subject, one wonders just how many DNA samples one might collect from a prostitute. Their work gets pretty intimate. One of these two fiends was on the existing database yet that doesn't seem to have been enough for the police - they want us all on the database, so they can trawl through every little sample they find at a crime scene, presumably using more computer power than Los Alamos to match up then round up casual crime scene visitors who will have nothing to do with the crime yet inevitably some will end up having to explain their innocent presence there.

No, it's time to call a halt to this expansion of the creepy, big brother state. My DNA is part of me. I may unwittingly leave bits of it lying around all over the place but to take some off me for cataloguing and storage is it seems to me a breach of habeas corpus. You're asking to hold a little bit of me in perpetuity, like a miniature electronic tag so you can reel me in whenever my DNA appears anywhere near a crime.

The fact is that Steve Wright and Mark Dixie were caught and were convicted. The existence or not of their DNA on a super-duper database doesn't seem to have prevented justice being done eventually. Good old police work was what did for them. That's where it should stop.

Trackback URL for this post:

http://jockcoats.me/trackback/816

  • Post to Twitter
Syndicate content

Relevant Content

Here are some stories that may be on related subjects, based on the tags used in this post:

Blogosphere of the Libertarian Left
Ring Owner: Thomas Knapp  Site: Blogosphere of the Libertarian Left
Free Site Ring from Bravenet Free Site Ring from Bravenet Free Site Ring from Bravenet Free Site Ring from Bravenet Free Site Ring from Bravenet
Get Your Free Web Ring
by Bravenet.com
Printed (hosted) by M5Hosting , San Diego, CA 92122, USA. Published and Promoted by Jock Coats , OXFORD, OX3 0FF. The views expressed are those of Jock Coats and any other contributors, and not M5Hosting. Developed using the Drupal Content Management System on Debian GNU/Linux servers. Theme by Jock Coats, from a heavily modified Drupal Zen template.