How the state corrupts the "free" market

Printer-friendly versionSend to friendPDF version

Libertarians often go on about how the state, whilst pretending to promote a free market actually more often than not corrupts that market through its own actions - protection, government contracts and so on and that this leads to the skewing of the market towards bigger corporations. I came across a good example today. The chief executive of an Oxfordshire based construction company Leadbitter (who are amongst other things building new blocks on my halls site now here at Brookes) writes for the local paper that:

The only crumb of comfort for Leadbitter is that changes in Government guidelines should soon mean the company will qualify at least to bid for large-scale, post-2011 Government projects — for example, under the Government’s Building Schools for the Future programme.

At present it is frozen out of the framework of firms that may make such bids because only companies with national coverage may do so; and that disqualifies Leadbitter. Despite being the UK’s 25th biggest builder — with offices in Plymouth, Bristol, Cardiff, Southampton, Sittingbourne, and Exeter (as well as its Abingdon HQ) – it still counts as a regional builder, not a national one.

[From Construction chief: Worst is yet to come (From The Oxford Times)]

The UK's 25th largest builder is not allowed to bid for a huge raft of government contracts. It is certainly big enough to deal with our £40m+ contracts for halls, so why not schools, say? Because the bigger firms have some clout that gets them government contracts - I can't believe that's in line with EU tendering rules, but there we go...big government, sponsoring big business, to the exclusion of local firms employing local people.

The whole of public sector procurement, from what I can see, is just the same. You'll find the same half dozen software firms appearing on shortlists for local authorities' back office systems for example. The same small group of companies bidding to take over admin functions in the public sector - in the vanguard of which is Capita, unsurprisingly founded and led by a former civil servant insider. And so on.

Do you see? This is NOT a free market. Those chosen few enjoy vast amounts of patronage and privilege at our expense - cartels and monopolies always push up prices or push down quality and we're the ones paying for all this, not only in our taxes but, if we don't work for these specially favoured companies, our jobs and livelihoods potentially.

0
No votes yet
Your rating: None

Comments

Cor, wouldn't it be nice to imagine a future where we can't believe that we ever needed to point this sort of crap out? 

Charlotte Gore's last blog post... As If To Wind Me Up Deliberately....

The OGC (Office of Government Commerce) is very keen on using "frameworks".  The idea is to pre-approve a number of companies for a purpose. 

 

Let's say you're a school and you want to buy some interactive whiteboards (we had slates in my day).  The relevant Government body (Becta, in this case) will invite companies selling IWBs to come onto their framework.  There'll be lots of checks that the company can do what it says, has a certain level of capitalisation, ticks all the standard boxes (e.g. insurance, equal opps).   Some get on the list, some don't.

 

The school has the option of buying it's iwbs from "Bob's second hand Interactive White Boards" round the corner, but it's recommended that it makes its life easier by choosing from the approved list.

 

Does this act as a barrier to entry into the market?  Yes.  Getting on one of these lists is a lot of work. 

 

But the Govt. would argue that the State is sharing the procurement burden so, instead of the financial checks being run on companies thousands of times by individual schools, they only need to be run once.  They'd show you numbers that it saves the public sector millions of pounds compared to a genuinely free market, and that the public sector isn't forced to use the frameworks.

Interesting debate going on here:

http://www.facebook.com/topic.php?topic=4568&post=23841&uid=2204445860#topic_top

Seem I am not the only one to find the "Libertarians" from your side of the tracks a matter of concern

Syndicate content
Printed (hosted) by M5Hosting , San Diego, CA 92122, USA. Published and Promoted by Jock Coats , OXFORD, OX3 0FF. The views expressed are those of Jock Coats and any other contributors, and not M5Hosting. Developed using the Drupal Content Management System on Debian GNU/Linux servers. Theme by Jock Coats, from a heavily modified Drupal Zen template.